Statins reduce cardiovascular risk only for as long as you take them. Stop, and cholesterol returns to its previous level within weeks and the risk reduction goes with it. So for most people treatment is intended to be long term. That is not the same as never being reviewed - there are situations where stopping is entirely reasonable, and a normal cholesterol reading while on treatment is not one of them, because that reading is the treatment working.
This is a discussion to have with your GP rather than a decision to make at home.
Why a good result is not a finishing line
The commonest reason people stop is a letter saying their cholesterol is now normal. It is an understandable reading of the situation and a mistaken one: the number is normal because the statin is lowering it. Withdraw the drug and the liver resumes producing cholesterol at its previous rate.
The comparison worth holding onto is blood pressure. Nobody expects to stop blood pressure tablets because their readings came down - the readings came down because of the tablets. Statins work the same way, and our guide to blood pressure treatment covers the same logic.
Two different situations
Secondary prevention means you have already had a heart attack, stroke, angina, or arterial disease elsewhere. Here the case for continuing is strongest: the risk of another event is high, and the benefit from a statin is correspondingly large. Stopping in this group is rarely advisable, and where side effects are the problem the usual answer is a different statin or a lower dose rather than nothing.
Primary prevention means you have not had an event, and the statin was started because a risk calculation suggested it was worthwhile. The absolute benefit for any one person is smaller here, the balance is finer, and there is more legitimate room for discussion about whether you want to continue.
Knowing which category you are in changes the conversation, and many people are not sure. It is a reasonable thing to ask.
When stopping is genuinely reasonable
- Intolerable side effects that persist after switching. Most muscle symptoms turn out not to be caused by the statin, and a change of drug or dose resolves many that are - our guide to statins and muscle pain covers how to establish which.
- Limited life expectancy or advanced frailty. A preventive medicine works over years. Where the horizon is shorter, the benefit may never be realised while the burden is immediate, and stopping is a recognised part of good care rather than giving up.
- Pregnancy, or planning one. Statins are generally stopped, and this should be planned in advance rather than discovered late.
- Serious interacting illness or a new medicine that cannot safely be combined.
- A change in the risk picture that makes the original calculation no longer applicable.
Deprescribing is now an active part of practice, and reducing the number of medicines someone takes is a legitimate goal in its own right, particularly for older people on long lists.
Does diet and exercise mean you can stop?
Lifestyle change genuinely lowers cardiovascular risk, and it is worth doing whether or not you take a statin. But the effect on LDL cholesterol from diet alone is generally more modest than a statin achieves, and much of your cholesterol level is determined by how much your liver makes rather than by what you eat.
Some people with mildly raised cholesterol and no other risk factors do bring their numbers into range with sustained change, and in that situation a review is entirely fair. For someone with familial hypercholesterolaemia, or with established arterial disease, it is not a realistic substitute.
How to have the conversation
Say plainly that you would like to review whether you still need it, and ask:
- Am I on this for primary or secondary prevention?
- What is my estimated risk with the statin, and without it?
- Is there a lower dose or a different statin worth trying first?
- If I stop, what would we monitor and when would we reconsider?
Asking for the numbers is reasonable and most practices can produce them. A decision made with them is a different thing from one made on a general unease about being on tablets.
What not to do
Do not stop quietly and say nothing at your next review. It leaves you with the cardiovascular risk and leaves your record showing treatment you are not taking - so future decisions get made on a false picture.
Unlike some medicines, statins do not cause withdrawal effects and do not need tapering, so stopping is physically straightforward. That is precisely why the decision deserves the thought that the act itself does not require. Our guide to monitoring long-term medicines covers what a proper review should include.
More on how the main families of medicine work in the Medicines section, including When Should You Take Your Statin?.