Working out whether a symptom comes from the medicine or from the thing the medicine is treating is one of the genuinely hard problems in everyday medicine. Fatigue, low mood, poor concentration, nausea and aches belong to dozens of conditions and hundreds of drugs. Getting it wrong is costly in both directions - stopping an effective treatment for no reason, or enduring a fixable side effect for years.
Why it is so difficult
Medicines are prescribed for conditions whose symptoms overlap with common side effects.
Depression causes fatigue, poor sleep, reduced libido and poor concentration - and so do several antidepressants.
Heart failure causes breathlessness and fatigue - and so do beta blockers, particularly in the first weeks.
Diabetes causes tiredness and neuropathy - and metformin causes B12 deficiency, which causes both.
Illness itself causes most of these symptoms regardless of treatment, and so does being unwell enough to need treatment at all.
Timing is the strongest clue
The single most useful piece of information, and the one most often lost.
Did the symptom start within days or weeks of starting the medicine, or of a dose increase? That points strongly to the drug.
Did it predate the medicine? Then it is probably not the drug, though the medicine could be worsening it.
Did it start months later, with no change? Less likely to be the drug - though not impossible, since the ACE inhibitor cough can begin months in, DRESS appears weeks later, and olmesartan enteropathy arrives years afterwards.
Write down when things started. Reconstructing it six months later from memory is unreliable in a predictable direction: people attribute to whatever they already suspect.
See keeping a side effect diary.
Dose relationship
Did it worsen when the dose went up, and improve when it went down?
That pattern is strong evidence, and it is one of the reasons doses are increased gradually.
Not all side effects are dose-related - allergic reactions are not - but most of the common ones are.
Stopping and restarting
The definitive test is stopping the medicine and seeing what happens, and if appropriate restarting it later.
Done properly this settles most questions. Done badly it creates new problems.
The rules: one medicine at a time, so you can tell what changed. Taper where needed, since several medicines cause rebound or withdrawal. Allow enough time for the drug to clear - days for most, weeks for fluoxetine or amiodarone. And agree in advance what would count as improvement.
Never do this with medicines where stopping is dangerous - anti-epileptics, steroid replacement, anticoagulants after a recent clot, transplant medicines, or clozapine.
See stopping a medicine that never worked and restarting a medicine after a break.
Withdrawal is not the illness returning
A specific and very common confusion.
Stopping a proton pump inhibitor causes rebound acid for a few weeks, which feels exactly like the reflux returning - and traps people into restarting.
Stopping an antidepressant causes discontinuation symptoms that get read as relapse.
Stopping a decongestant nasal spray causes rebound congestion.
Withdrawal appears within days, frequently includes physical features that were never part of the original problem, and settles over days to weeks. Relapse is slower and looks like the original condition.
See medicines and your gut over time.
Things worth testing before blaming the drug
Several fixable conditions present as vague drug-like symptoms, and a blood test settles them.
Low sodium - confusion, unsteadiness, falls, headache. Caused by thiazides and SSRIs.
Underactive thyroid - fatigue, weight gain, low mood. Caused by lithium and amiodarone.
B12 deficiency - fatigue and neuropathy. Caused by metformin and long-term acid suppression.
Anaemia - fatigue and breathlessness, sometimes from slow gastrointestinal blood loss on anti-inflammatories or anticoagulants.
Kidney function, which changes what doses are appropriate.
These are drug effects that look like other illnesses, which is the mirror image of the problem.
See medicines that lower your sodium and medicines that affect your thyroid.
Expectation plays a part
Worth acknowledging honestly, and without dismissing anyone.
People told to expect a side effect report it more often, and people who know they have switched product report more problems even when the product is identical.
That does not mean symptoms are imagined - the experience is real. It means a single person's impression is genuinely hard to interpret, which is why a structured stop-and-restart beats reasoning about it.
The statin muscle-symptom literature is the clearest example: blinded trials found similar rates on drug and placebo, while unblinded experience says otherwise.
When not to investigate slowly
Some symptoms are not candidates for watchful waiting.
Seek help promptly for a rash with fever or blistering, swelling of the face or throat, severe abdominal pain, black tarry stools, dark urine with muscle pain, unexplained bruising or a sore throat with fever, yellowing of the eyes, sudden visual change, or thoughts of harming yourself.
See warning signs never to ignore.
How to raise it
Bring the timeline, not the conclusion. "This started eleven days after the dose went up" is far more useful than "I think this tablet disagrees with me".
Ask directly whether the symptom is a recognised effect of anything on your list - and remember that the anticholinergic burden of several mild drugs together can exceed one strong one.
See medication reviews.
The Side Effects section covers more on side effects and safety - Medicines That Cause Nausea is closely related to this one.