Supplements are sold on the implication that more nutrition is better, and for most people eating a reasonable diet that is not how it works. A short list has genuine evidence, almost all of it for specific groups rather than the general population. The rest does little, some of it interacts with medicines, and a few are actively harmful in excess.
The ones with real evidence
Vitamin D. UK advice is that everyone should consider a supplement during the autumn and winter months, when there is insufficient sunlight to make it, and that some groups should take it year-round - people with little sun exposure, those who cover their skin, and people with darker skin. Deficiency causes bone problems and is genuinely common here.
Folic acid before and during early pregnancy, which substantially reduces neural tube defects. It works best started before conception, and a higher dose is advised for some people including those with diabetes and those on certain anti-epileptics.
Vitamin B12 for anyone on a vegan diet, since it is found almost exclusively in animal products. Deficiency causes anaemia and irreversible nerve damage if prolonged.
Iron where deficiency has been demonstrated on a blood test - not speculatively, since excess iron is harmful.
See vitamin D, folic acid and vitamin B12.
Where a medicine creates the need
This is the most relevant category here, and it is frequently missed.
Metformin reduces B12 absorption, and the resulting neuropathy gets attributed to diabetes. B12 should be checked periodically.
Proton pump inhibitors reduce absorption of B12, magnesium, calcium and iron with long-term use.
Long-term steroids warrant attention to bone health, frequently with calcium and vitamin D alongside bone protection.
Methotrexate requires folic acid - on different days from the methotrexate.
Isoniazid requires pyridoxine to prevent nerve damage.
See medicines and your gut over time and methotrexate.
Where the evidence is thin
Multivitamins in people eating an adequate diet - large trials have found little benefit for most outcomes.
Antioxidant supplements, where high-dose beta-carotene increased lung cancer risk in smokers, and high-dose vitamin E has not shown benefit.
Vitamin C for preventing colds, which does not work, though it may shorten them slightly.
Fish oil for general cardiovascular prevention, where the large trials have been disappointing - prescription-strength preparations for very high triglycerides are a different matter. See omega-3.
Calcium supplements for everyone, which are appropriate where dietary intake is low or alongside bone protection, and not otherwise. See calcium supplements.
Probiotics, where evidence is mixed and product-specific.
Supplements that interfere with medicines
The reason to mention them at every review.
St John's wort is a potent enzyme inducer and has caused transplant rejection and contraceptive failure.
Vitamin K supplements affect warfarin - and the advice with dietary vitamin K is consistency rather than avoidance.
High-dose fish oil, garlic, ginkgo, ginseng and turmeric have mild antiplatelet effects that add to prescribed blood thinners.
Iron, calcium, magnesium and zinc bind several medicines in the gut - separate them by a couple of hours.
Biotin interferes with several laboratory tests, including thyroid tests, producing results that look abnormal when function is normal.
Kelp and seaweed contain large and variable amounts of iodine, which disturbs the thyroid.
Grapefruit extract, and several herbal preparations.
See supplements that interfere with your medicines and medicines that affect your thyroid.
More is not better
Several vitamins are fat-soluble and accumulate.
Excess vitamin A is harmful and is specifically avoided in pregnancy, which is why liver is not recommended then. Excess vitamin D raises calcium and damages the kidneys. Excess selenium and zinc are both toxic.
Taking several products at once frequently means taking the same nutrient two or three times over, since multivitamins overlap with individual supplements.
Food first, where it is realistic
For most nutrients, food delivers them alongside everything else that comes with a varied diet, and in amounts the body handles well.
That said, telling someone to eat better is not a plan, and for the genuinely evidence-backed items above - vitamin D in a British winter, folic acid before conception, B12 on a vegan diet - a supplement is the sensible answer rather than a second-best one. The distinction is between correcting a specific, identified gap and taking something in the hope of general improvement.
Practical approach
Test rather than guess where a deficiency is suspected - it is cheap and it avoids treating something you do not have.
Tell your prescriber and pharmacist what you take, including anything herbal. Supplements are not inert simply because they are sold freely.
Bring the actual packets to a medication review, since these are the items most often missing from the record.
Stop them before surgery where advised - several affect bleeding.
See medication reviews and which medicines to stop before surgery.
Related reading: Taking Medicines With a Small Appetite, with more on taking medicines day to day in Usage.