A change of manufacturer for a tablet is usually cosmetic. A change of device is not. With inhalers and injection pens, the drug may be identical while the thing you have to do with your hands and your breath is completely different - and with inhalers the required breathing technique can be the exact opposite of what you have been doing for years. Errors at a device switch come from the device, not the molecule.
The two inhaler types need opposite breathing
This is the crucial point and it is frequently not explained.
Pressurised aerosol inhalers need a slow, steady breath in, started just before pressing, and continued for several seconds - then holding your breath.
Dry powder inhalers need a hard, fast, deep breath in to pull the powder out of the device.
Someone switched from one to the other without retraining will use the wrong technique, and the medicine will largely not reach the lungs.
Worse, it feels fine - dry powder inhalers deliver no sensation, so people frequently believe they have taken a dose when they have not.
Ask for your technique to be checked whenever the device changes, and ask to demonstrate it rather than just being told.
See using your inhaler properly.
Other differences that matter
Priming. Some devices need priming before first use or after a period unused; others do not.
Loading a dose. Twist, click, lever, or press - and some devices waste the dose if you shake them after loading.
Dose counters. Some count down, some have none, some show a coloured warning zone. Knowing when yours is empty matters, particularly for a reliever.
Spacer compatibility. Spacers fit pressurised inhalers only, and not every spacer fits every inhaler. If you use one, check the new device fits before you leave.
Rinsing. Still needed after a steroid, whatever the device.
Potency is not always equivalent. Beclometasone is the clearest example - extrafine preparations are roughly twice as potent as standard ones at the same nominal dose, so a switch without a dose change delivers double or half. See beclometasone.
Why switches happen
Several reasons, and they are not all cost.
A supply problem. A formulary change. A move to a lower-carbon dry powder device. A biosimilar replacing an originator. Or a clinical reason specific to you.
Environmental switching is worth a note: dry powder inhalers have a far smaller carbon footprint, and switching is encouraged where suitable. But it is not suitable for everyone - young children, frail older people and those with severe airflow limitation may not generate the inspiratory flow needed.
If you cannot manage the new device, say so. That is a clinical reason to switch back, not a failure on your part.
See medicines and the environment.
Injection devices
The same principle applies to pens.
Different manufacturers' devices differ in the force needed, the dialling mechanism, the needle cover, the hold time after injecting, and whether the needle is visible.
Some contain citrate buffer and some do not, which noticeably changes stinging.
Some needle covers contain a latex derivative - worth flagging if you have a latex allergy.
Ask to be shown the new device and to try it under supervision. Manufacturers provide training materials, and specialist nurses do this routinely.
See injecting yourself at home and biosimilars explained.
Do not mix old and new
A specific hazard during a switch.
Having both the old and the new device in the house leads to taking both, or to using the old one as a reliever without realising it contains a preventer.
Finish or return the old supply once you have changed, and make sure everyone involved in your care knows which device is current.
Return old inhalers to a pharmacy rather than binning them - even empty ones retain propellant.
See disposing of patches, creams and liquids.
What to do at the counter
Do not leave until you have been shown how it works. This is the one situation where waiting a few extra minutes is clearly worth it.
Check the drug name and strength, not just that it is "the brown one" - colours are not standardised and change between manufacturers.
Update your medicines list with the new device name.
Ask what to do if you cannot manage it.
See keeping a medicines list and switching between manufacturers.
If control worsens afterwards
Report it. Needing your reliever more often after a device switch is a signal that the new device is not delivering properly - most often a technique problem, which is fixable.
Call 999 if your reliever is not helping or not lasting, or you are too breathless to speak in full sentences.
If this was useful, Importing a Medicine Not Available Here is worth reading next, and Prescriptions collects the rest.